A protein shake is supposed to make your day easier, not leave you queasy for the next hour. If shakes make you feel sick, the protein itself is rarely the problem. It is usually something else in the tub, or the way and the time you are drinking it. Here are the six most common causes and what to do about each one.
Why do protein shakes make me feel sick?
Most shake-related nausea traces back to one of six things:
- Lactose in dairy-based powders such as whey concentrate.
- A milk allergy, which is an immune reaction rather than a digestive one.
- Sugar alcohols such as xylitol, sorbitol and erythritol.
- Added fibers and thickeners such as inulin or chicory root.
- Drinking too much, too fast, or on a completely empty stomach.
- Drinking it right before or during a hard workout.
The quickest way to narrow it down is to read the ingredient list on your powder, then change one thing at a time.
Is the dairy in my shake the problem?
Very often, yes. Whey and casein come from milk, and most whey powders carry some of milk's sugar, lactose. Digesting lactose takes an enzyme called lactase, and about 65% of people have a reduced ability to digest lactose after infancy. In the US, the National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases estimates that about 36% of people have lactose malabsorption. Lactose that is not digested is fermented by gut bacteria, which can cause nausea, bloating, gas and diarrhea. Whey concentrate keeps more lactose than whey isolate, so it is the more likely of the two to cause trouble.
A milk allergy is different. Milk is one of the nine major food allergens in the US, and whey is one of the milk proteins that can trigger a reaction. Allergic symptoms can include hives, swelling, vomiting or wheezing. If you notice any of those, stop and see a doctor rather than troubleshooting on your own.
The simplest test for both is to take dairy out of the shake entirely. A plant protein made from pea and rice contains no lactose and no milk proteins, so if your nausea goes away after switching, you have your answer. For a fuller comparison, read pea protein vs whey.
Can sweeteners in protein powder cause nausea?
They can, and sugar alcohols are the usual suspects. In a randomized, placebo-controlled study, a single 50-gram dose of xylitol taken in a liquid significantly increased nausea, bloating and watery stools, and 50 grams of erythritol also increased reports of nausea. Smaller amounts of erythritol were well tolerated. Sorbitol is potent enough that foods likely to supply 50 grams a day must carry the warning "Excess consumption may have a laxative effect."
One scoop will not contain anywhere near 50 grams, but sugar alcohols add up across a day of bars, gum and "zero sugar" drinks, and some people are more sensitive than others. If your powder lists xylitol, sorbitol, maltitol or erythritol, try one without them.
Could added fibers or gums be the cause?
They could. Many powders add fiber for texture or to make a "high fiber" claim, and inulin from chicory root is a common choice. In a controlled trial, inulin fibers tended to increase digestive symptoms, most often gas and then bloating, and a 10-gram dose of oligofructose noticeably increased them. Doses up to 10 grams of native inulin were well tolerated by most people, so this is about how much you take and how sensitive you are.
Gums and thickeners such as xanthan and guar are there to make a shake feel creamy. Some people with sensitive stomachs prefer to avoid them, and a well-formulated powder does not need them.
Does when and how you drink it matter?
It does. A large, cold shake gulped down in a couple of minutes is a lot for a stomach to take in at once, and many people find shakes harder to handle first thing in the morning before they have eaten anything. Sipping more slowly, using a little more liquid, or having your shake with a small meal are simple changes worth trying first.
Timing around exercise matters too. Digestive complaints are common in athletes, and studies suggest 30% to 50% of athletes experience them. During intense exercise, blood flow to the gut drops, especially if you are dehydrated, which is thought to be one of the main causes. If shakes only bother you before training, move yours to after your workout, when it also does its most useful job: supporting recovery.
Is plant protein easier on your stomach?
For many people, yes, mainly because it removes dairy. A plant protein cannot contain lactose or milk proteins, which takes the two most common triggers off the table in one switch. Plant proteins are not hard to digest either: in a randomized trial, pea protein's digestibility was similar to that of casein, a milk protein.
The rest of the formula still matters. A plant powder made with sugar alcohols, inulin and gums can upset your stomach for the same reasons a whey powder can. Look for:
- Pea, rice or a blend of plant proteins high on the ingredient list.
- No sugar alcohols and no artificial sweeteners.
- No gums or fillers.
- Independent testing, with results you can look up.
That is the brief we gave ourselves for So Lean & So Clean: 23g of complete organic plant protein from pea and rice, no added sugar, and no stevia, erythritol, gums or artificial sweeteners. It also includes a digestive enzyme blend. If you want something simpler still, Longevity League is made for sensitive stomachs, with no added sugar, gums or fillers. For more on what to look for, see how to choose a clean plant-based protein powder.
How do you stop feeling sick after a protein shake?
- Read the label. Note any dairy, sugar alcohols, inulin or chicory root, and gums.
- Take dairy out first. Switch to a plant protein for a week and see whether the nausea stops.
- Cut the additives. If you are already dairy-free, choose a powder without sugar alcohols, added fibers or gums.
- Slow down. Sip over 10 to 15 minutes and add more water or plant milk.
- Don't drink it on an empty stomach. Pair it with a banana, oats or a small meal.
- Move it after your workout if it only bothers you when you train.
Making your shake with whole foods can help too. Blending in fruit, oats or nut butter turns it into something closer to a meal. Our recipes have plenty of ideas.
When should you see a doctor?
Occasional queasiness that goes away when you change powders is not a cause for concern. See a doctor if you have nausea that persists after you stop drinking shakes, vomiting, blood in your stool, unexplained weight loss, or any sign of an allergic reaction such as hives, swelling or trouble breathing. Get emergency help for trouble breathing. If you are pregnant, take medication or have a digestive condition, talk to your doctor before adding a protein supplement.